Kelly is the BEST great JRs steak superb

Everything is so delicious I've never got a bad meal and the service is good.

We have been coming to this location a lot since we located it. It is by far the nicest J&Rs. The restaurant is not crazy like the others. Very friendly staff. The food is always good nice portions. We love the bread and pasta before but most of all it’s a pleasant clean atmosphere ,, I just went on Sunday to receive my free Birthday dinner which is so nice when u sign up on their email. Thank you.

Great cozy place to have great quality steak. The portion sizes are well fulfilling and prices are reasonable. Atmosphere is relaxing and very family oriented. Staff is very friendly especially the waiter I had which was nice since a lot of places don't have friendly staff. This is definitely a place to go if you haven't tried and if you did, then you have to go again.

You can't beat the lunch specials, especially the Prime Rib

Some of the best steaks on Long Island. Fair prices, huge portions. I will be back!

I've been to J&R's In Islip once every couple of months for years and have never been disappointed. The service is excellent as is the food. You by far out do the competition. Service, Food, atmosphere, not jammed in seats, Great Specials. Why go anywhere else!!

Friendly staff, clean restaurant (including bathrooms!), delicious food, decent menu and priced well.

Affordable and filling. Great non-mayo pasta salad before the meal. Okay beer selection."

"Had the jr special large ribeye was very good 24 ounce"