
Think you’re a big eater? Think you could finish a 76-ounce steak and baked potato in one hour? If so, you might be the next Champion of J&R’s Islip 76-ounce Steak Challenge!
The challenge is simple: eat the entire steak and potato in one hour. If you succeed, the meal is on us! But if you fail, you’ll have to pay for it.
The steak is a massive top sirloin, weighing in at a whopping 76 ounces. That’s almost five pounds of meat! And you have to eat the baked potato too.
So if you’re up for the challenge, come on down to J&R’s Islip and give it a try! But be warned, it’s not for the faint of heart. Only a handful of people have ever succeeded in completing the challenge.
Here are some tips for those who are brave enough to attempt the challenge:
- Come hungry! You’ll need to have a big appetite to take on this challenge.
- Start slowly. Don’t try to eat everything all at once. Take your time and savor the flavors.
- Drink plenty of water. This will help to keep you hydrated and prevent you from getting too full too quickly.
- Take breaks. If you need to, take a few minutes to rest and regroup. Don’t try to power through the challenge if you’re feeling overwhelmed.
- Have fun! This is a challenge, but it’s also an opportunity to have some fun and test your limits.
So what are you waiting for? Come on down to J&R’s Islip and try your luck at the 76-ounce Steak Challenge!
Winners also get a J&R’s T-Shirt and are featured on this page and our social media channels.
Champions

Peter S 10/25/25 🏆Champion!🏆

Shane T 8/21/25 🏆 CHAMPION 🏆

Joe N 7/10/25 🏆 CHAMPION 🏆

Joe F 3/29/25 🏆 CHAMPION 🏆

Matt A. 6/7/24 🏆 CHAMPION 🏆

Dj M 4/29/24 🏆 CHAMPION 🏆

Robert M 4/24/24 🏆 CHAMPION 🏆

Wayne A. 2/4/24 🏆 CHAMPION 🏆

Shawn B. 7/7/23 🏆 CHAMPION 🏆

Teddy T 4/29/23 🏆 CHAMPION 🏆

beardmeatsfood 11/14/21 🏆 Champion 🏆

Richard M 2/25/22 🏆 Champion 🏆
Follow Us on Instagram for the latest on our 76-Ounce Steak Challenge Champions and Contenders as well as Specials and Other Important Posts (click the Instagram logo below).
Contenders

Nick H 4/5/26 Attempted

Lauren F 4/3/26 Attempted

Ray E 10/25/25 Attempted

Javier A 10/24/25 Attempted

Jose C 10/7/25 Attempted

Joe C 8/22/25 Attempted

Kenny E. 4/28/25 Attempted

Thomas 11/16/24 Attempted

Richie 11/16/24 Attempted

Paul G. 10/19/24 Attempted

Ho Ming 9/22/24 Attempted

Brian R 9/1/24 Attempted

Chris M 8/22/24 Attempted

Dan F. 5/19/24 Attempted

Peter R. 5/3/24 Attempted

Nick M 4/29/24 Attempted

Ismael Attempted 4/27/24

Ben V. 4/6/24 Attempted

Drew S. 12/27/23 Attempted

Mickey M 9/3/23 Attempted

Vito T 6/26/23 Attempted

Marco M 4/29/23 Attempted

Anthony P 4/17/23 Attempted

Rich W 4/9/23 Attempted

Nathan 9/18/22 Attempted

Jim B. 5/17/22 Attempted

Justin P 4/4/26 Attempted

Joe N 12/28/25 Attempted

Josh M 11/18/25 Attempted

Chris S 10/25/25 Attempted

Edward G 10/24/25 Attempted

Jermain R 8/31/25 Attempted

Matt R 8/23/25 Attempted

Chase F 8/3/25 Attempted

Brian B 7/16/25 Attempted

Leo F 7/10/25 Attempted

Dylan S 7/3/25 Attempted

Steven K 4/19/25 Attempted

Billy V 4/16/25 Attempted

John P 4/6/25 Attempted

Steven P 013025 Attempted

John 11/16/24 Attempted

Andrew 11/16/24 Attempted

Bont V 9/22/24 Attempted

Cory R 8/4/24 Attempted

Giancarlo 6/23/24 Attempted

Will F 5/3/24 Attempted

Nicholas O 4/7/24 Attempted

John M. 11/8/23 Attempted

Salvatore G 8/27/23 Attempted

Paul G 6/24/23 Attempted

Daman A 4/23/23 Attempted

Anthony P 4/17/23 Attempted

Hal A. & Thomas G 3/11/23 Attempted

Jimmy B. 5/17/22 Attempted

Joe V 2/8/23 Attempted

Domenic M 2/25/22 Attempted

