76-Ounce Steak Challenge

J&Rs Steakhouse, Islip, NY 76-ounce Steak Challenge

Think you’re a big eater? Think you could finish a 76-ounce steak, side salad, and baked potato in one hour? If so, you might be the next Champion of J&R’s Islip 76-ounce Steak Challenge!

The challenge is simple: eat the entire steak, salad, and potato in one hour. If you succeed, the meal is on us! But if you fail, you’ll have to pay for it.

The steak is a massive top sirloin, weighing in at a whopping 76 ounces. That’s almost five pounds of meat! The salad is also generous and you have to eat the baked potato too.

So if you’re up for the challenge, come on down to J&R’s Islip and give it a try! But be warned, it’s not for the faint of heart. Only a handful of people have ever succeeded in completing the challenge.

Here are some tips for those who are brave enough to attempt the challenge:

  • Come hungry! You’ll need to have a big appetite to take on this challenge.
  • Start slowly. Don’t try to eat everything all at once. Take your time and savor the flavors.
  • Drink plenty of water. This will help to keep you hydrated and prevent you from getting too full too quickly.
  • Take breaks. If you need to, take a few minutes to rest and regroup. Don’t try to power through the challenge if you’re feeling overwhelmed.
  • Have fun! This is a challenge, but it’s also an opportunity to have some fun and test your limits.

So what are you waiting for? Come on down to J&R’s Islip and try your luck at the 76-ounce Steak Challenge!


Wayne A. 2/4/24 🏆 CHAMPION 🏆

Shawn B. 7/7/23 🏆 CHAMPION 🏆

Teddy T 4/29/23 🏆 CHAMPION 🏆

beardmeatsfood 11/14/21 🏆 Champion 🏆

Richard M 2/25/22 🏆 Champion 🏆


Follow Us on Instagram for the latest on our 76-Ounce Steak Challenge Champions and Contenders as well as Specials and Other Important Posts (click the Instagram logo below).


Ben V. 040624 Attempted

Drew S. 12/27/23 Attempted

Drew S. 12/27/23 Attempted

Mickey M 9/3/23 Attempted

Mickey M 9/3/23 Attempted

Vito T 6/26/23 Attempted

Marco M 4/29/23 Attempted

Anthony P 4/17/23 Attempted

Rich W 4/9/23 Attempted

Nathan 9/18/22 Attempted

Nathan 9/18/22 Attempted

Jim B. 5/17/22 Attempted

Domenic M 2/25/22 Attempted

Nicholas O 4/7/24 attempted

John M. 11/8/23 Attempted

Salvatore G 8/27/23 Attempted

Paul G 6/24/23 Attempted

Daman A 4/23/23 Attempted

Anthony P 4/17/23 Attempted

Hal A. & Thomas G 3/11/23 Attempted

Jimmy B. 5/17/22 Attempted

Joe V 2/8/23 Attempted